Late in the fifteenth century the Germans were mortified
to discover that, although a nation, they had not become a state. They found
that the centre of political power had shifted westward, that the destinies of
Europe were now controlled by the French, the English and the Spaniards. These
nations had perfected a new form of autocracy, more vigorous, more workmanlike
in structure, than any medieval form of government. Germany in the meanwhile
had clung to all that was worst and feeblest in the old order; her monarchy,
and the institutions connected with it, had been reduced to impotence. The same
process of decay had operated in the minor states of the eastern group. In
Scandinavia, in Hungary, in the Slavonic lands, the tree of royal power was
enveloped and strangled by the undergrowth of a bastard feudalism, by the territorial
power of aristocracies which, under cover of administrative titles, converted
whole provinces into family estates and claimed over their tenants the divine
right of unlimited and irresponsible sovereignty.
To investigate all the
reasons for the political backwardness of these eastern peoples would carry us
far afield. But one reason lies on the surface. Outside the free towns they had
produced no middle class; and their towns were neither numerous nor wealthy
enough to be important in national politics. They were not even represented in the
national assemblies. In consequence the sovereigns of these states were obliged
to govern by the help of aristocratic factions; to purchase recognition by the
grant of larger and larger privileges; and for the sake of power to strip
themselves of the resources which alone could give their power any meaning. But
good government in the Middle Ages was only another name for a public-spirited
and powerful monarchy. Such monarchies existed in the western states; they
rested upon the shoulders of a middle class of small landowners and wealthy
merchants, too weak to defend themselves in a state of nature, a war of all
against all, but collectively strong enough to overawe the forces of anarchy.