A History of Greek Philosophy / THE ELEATICS / MELISSUS

Page 2

By similar treatment of other conceivable alternatives he proceeds to show that as the existent had no beginning so it can have no ending in time. From this, by a curious transition which Aristotle quotes as an example of loose reasoning, he concludes that the existent can have no limit in space either. As being thus unlimited it must be one, therefore immovable (there being nothing else into which it can move or change), and therefore always self-identical in extent and character. It cannot, therefore, have any body, for body has parts and is not therefore one.

Being incapable of change one might perhaps conclude that the absolutely existing being is incapable of any mental activity or consciousness. We have no authority for assuming that Melissus came to this conclusion; but there is a curious remark of Aristotle’s respecting this and previous philosophers of the school which certain critics have made to bear some such interpretation. He says: “Parmenides seems to hold by a Unity in thought, Melissus by a Material unity. Hence the first defined the One as limited, the second declared it to be unlimited. Xenophanes made no clear statement on this question; he simply, gazing up to the arch of heaven, declared, The One is God.”

First / Next Page of this chapter

Next Chapter : ANAXAGORAS / Previous Chapter : ZENO

A History of Greek Philosophy : Table of Contents

Reference address : https://www.ellopos.net/elpenor/greek-texts/ancient-greece/history-of-philosophy/melissus.asp?pg=2