Copperfield Text / Essays & Tools / Dickens Resources / Forum / Creative Writing  | Donate

David Copperfield Notes : The Undisciplined Heart

IN PRINT

 

Page 4

"Immaturity" marks the Undisciplined Heart

by Brenda Griffith

 

One element not addressed by Wanderer is the notion of the undisciplined heart as a synonym for immaturity- maturity defined as a recognition of the innate value of others and their opinions and a selfless acceptance of the genuine affection of others.

Note that Mrs. Strong (who originated the phrase for David) recognizes in her youth her own selfish desires (although they were kept completely to herself) toward the unworthy Mr. Maldon and could not see Doctor Strong's attachment to her for what it was.  Later, after Strong is told about his friend's suspicions and renews his sincere attentions to her, Mrs. Strong is frequently overcome by these displays, recognizing her own "undisciplined heart."  Her public profession of devotion to Doctor Strong is a powerful testimony to her self denial, her disciplined heart.  Even the Doctor doesn't expect this kind of maturity from his wife - whom he frequently refers to as young.

So isolated that he actually becomes more immature

Contrast Annie's behavior to David's - his struggle with his undisciplined heart is mostly kept to himself (although he tries once to have his Aunt "help" Dora - an offer which she very wisely rejects.)  He wanders geographically and mentally- so isolated that he actually becomes more immature- more undisciplined. He convices himself that it is noble and humble to sacrifice his love for Agnes in favor of a sibling-like relationship with her.  And he tries really hard and "succeeds" to a point- so much so that he hurts Agnes quite a bit.  There can't be a more selfish behavior-"noble" self-sacrifice! 

Fortunately, this can't last.  Agnes' disciplined heart admits her love for him (she really has sacrificed her life for him- bearing with his immaturity for a long time).  He, like Annie, capitulates to a true, selfless, love, and matures in the process. 

For both David and Annie the process of maturation cannot be accomplished in isolation- even though they both thought it noble to try.  We need others to help us discipline our hearts.

Brenda Griffith, June 2000

Publish your views

See also: 
Eiichi Hara, "The King and the Apprentice" (pdf).

Previous Page ||| First Page